TV Documentaries are Crap

Posted by | July 13, 2005 | media | No Comments

PBS’ Guns Germs and Steel documentary took an hour and several tons of jet fuel to explain, well nothing. The documentary merely stated, but neither explained nor tested the hypothesis.

A great shame, because the book is still a hypothesis worthy of testing. I saw Jared Diamond talk about a year ago, and he had plenty of new evidence to add.

P Z Myers says it best:

“The information density is appallingly low, and what we got in an hour was the equivalent of reading a handful” of pages from the book.”